NewsLocal News

Actions

'Very safe neighborhood': Brookside neighbors shocked after armed robbery at Earl's Premiere left 1 injured

Posted
and last updated
Earl's Premiere

KANSAS CITY, Mo — The Kansas City, Missouri, Police Department is investigating an armed robbery near east 59th and Holmes streets.

It happened Saturday night, just before close at Earl's Premiere.

Police say one person was assaulted while a pair of men robbed the restaurant and customers.

Tuesday morning Earl's Premier issued a statement on Instagram that says: Earl’s Premier extends heartfelt thanks for the outpouring of support and concern we’ve received from our neighbors, patrons, and friends in the wake of Saturday night’s incident.

We are relieved to report that no guests were present or injured during the robbery. While one staff member sustained a minor injury, their injuries did not require hospitalization, and they are recovering well. The safety and comfort of our guests, along with the incredible staff we have the privilege to work with every day, remain our top priorities.

As a locally owned establishment, we value the strong connections we share with the Kansas City community. In response to this incident, we are actively evaluating our security measures and working closely with law enforcement and city officials, whose assistance has been invaluable as we move forward.
Thank you again for your continued support. Wishing everyone a safe and happy New Year in 2025!

"There are people who have been here for 20, 30, 40 years — we love the neighborhood," said neighbor Mark Calvert. "It's a very, very safe neighborhood, so this is a big concern."

Mark Calvert
Mark Calvert

Other neighbors said the addition of Earl’s has improved the small strip of shops that sits on 59th Street.

Homeowners nearby said they didn’t hear any commotion Saturday night and were shocked to hear about the violent robbery.

Multiple people KSHB 41's Abby Dodge spoke to said the area has battled small acts of theft and property crime over the years, but Saturday's armed robbery is an escalation.

"It just kind of makes you wonder if it is going to be homes next," said neighbor Brad Matteuzzi.

Brad Matteuzzi
Brad Matteuzzi

Neighbors said the incident reminded them of Shaun Brady's death earlier this year.

Police said a group tried to steal a car, then shot and killed Brady outside of his Brookside restaurant.

"One more upset in a series of upsets," said neighbor Timothy Hayes. "It’s just sadness. And it’s frustrating."

Timothy Hayes
Timothy Hayes

Police are still investigating the armed robbery and had officers stop by Earl’s Premiere Monday afternoon to speak with the owners.

KSHB 41 reporter Abby Dodge covers consumer issues, personal budgeting and everyday spending. Share your story idea with Abby.